Puncuating a list of quesitons in a sentence
How should the following sentence be punctuated?
Only the Bible offers answers that make sense to the age-old questions “Who is man?” “Why is he here?” “What is the meaning of life?”
I think that at least the Chicago Manual of Style (CMoS) does provide clear guidelines on this, unlike what Jeff says (and what it suggests is, I think, fairly universally followed). I cite CMoS section numbers from the 15th edition in what follows.
In summary, the standard punctuation would be
Only the Bible offers answers that make sense to the age-old questions: Who is man? Why is he here? What is the meaning of life?
but it feels a bit overbearing and abrupt with the questions as separate sentences. I'd be tempted to make them clauses in a list, which also raises some more interesting punctuation aspects.
Only the Bible offers answers that make sense to the age-old questions: who is man? why is he here? and what is the meaning of life?
There are four aspects:
(i) The part up to "questions" is a complete sentence, and the three questions are a list which is "illustrating or amplifying" the part before. Thus you absolutely want a colon (CMoS 6.63).
(ii) If you keep the questions as separate sentences, then the colon introduces two or more full sentences and so they need capitalisation (CMoS 6.64), and the question marks end each sentence. If you go for the clauses route, then you wouldn't capitalise each question (CMoS 6.64), and
the question marks punctuate the list of questions themselves (i.e., you don't need commas and periods as well) because a period or comma never accompanies a question mark or exclamation point: "The latter two marks, being stronger, take precedence over the first two" (CMoS 6.123).
(iii) The quotes are not needed because these are "Commonly known facts, proverbs, and other familiar expressions" where the wording is not "taken directly from another work" (CMoS 11.5).
If these three questions were stated specifically by someone then you are citing them and (only) then would you use quotes, such as
Only the Bible offers answers that make sense to the age-old questions posed by Smith: "who is man?" "why is he here?" and "what is the meaning of life?"
NB: If they weren't questions, you'd have to worry about whether you're using the US-centric standard with punctuation always inside the quotes (CMoS 6.8), or the alternative UK-centric version (CMoS 6.10)—which I prefer—where punctuation marks always occur outside quotes (except when they're part of the quoted material). For example, CMoS (6.123) gives an example for the US style:
Her favorite songs are "Hello Dolly!" "Chicago," and "Come with Me."
In alternative style this would be
Her favourite songs are "Hello Dolly!", "Chicago", and "Come with Me".
(Using an Oxford comma and being unable to resist 'correcting' "favorite" to its UK spelling :-) It's arguable that the first comma should not be there because the exclamation point takes precedence (CMoS 6.123 again), but there is now a quote between and it looks very 'unbalanced' to me without it when using this UK-centric style.)
|link comment||edited Mar 03 '15 at 10:56 Stuart Rossiter New member|
Hero of the day
Person voted on the most questions.