Please check this paragraph, Sir
John, who was an intelligent young boy, had no father. His mother had to work as a security guard in the basement of a big office on New York Avenue to bring her son up. Massacring people was the order of the day in the city he lived. Unfortunately, one day Taoism, a young terrorist, killed John, and his dead body was lying in the street. The police took two hours to track down John's address. During the police enquiry, the people were nonchalant about this incident as they were afraid to get involved in this affair.
Sanjay, most of my comments today will be about style – the “art” of writing” – and less about grammar. In your first sentence, you have a choice of how to tell us about John. You can use a relative pronoun clause or an appositive. I’ll show you the difference:
John, who was an intelligent young boy, had no father.
John, an intelligent young boy, had no father.
With your second sentence, you also have several choices involving the verb form.
His mother had to work …
His mother worked …
The first, “had to work,” suggests the mother was compelled or forced to work. The second only conveys the fact that the mother worked. If you want to emphasize the mother’s need to work, you may wish to link the reason “to bring her son up” more closely with the result. You can do this by making the reason an introductory clause.
To bring her son up, the mother had to work …
The second sentence also offers opportunities to make the story more interesting, to spice it up. Here are some examples:
John’s mother had to toil …
To raise her son, John’s mother had to labor …
Your second sentence also suffers from “prepositional sprawl. You can streamline the sentence somewhat:
as a security guard in the basement of a New York Avenue office
Here is one version of the second sentence. I have indicated places <?> where you might add an adjective to make the story more descriptive. Pick your own words. Don’t overdo it.
To raise her <?> son, John’s mother had to labor as a security guard in the <?> basement of a <?> New York Avenue office.
To raise her only son, John’s mother had to labor as a security guard in the dingy basement of a soaring New York Avenue office.
I'll come back and comment on the rest of the story in another answer.
|link||answered Jul 09 '12 at 16:02 Jeff Pribyl Grammarly Fellow|
Hero of the day
Person gave the most answers!