fall / fall down
@ The bird had fallen from a nest.
@ The bird had fallen down from a nest.
Any further explanation between fell & fell down with explicit examples?
In my opinion, if something falls it is moving downward. But if something falls down it is usually a) Not intended to have fallen and b) Will/ or Has come to an inevitable stop. I.E. Landing on something 'The rock fell.' the rock moved downward 'The rock fell down' the rock moved downward and landed on something
The bird had fallen from a nest and The bird had fallen down from a nest.
The bird cannot fall from a nest, so using fell down is a stylistic choice for a writer/speaker. There is no real difference between fallen from a nest and fallen down from a nest.
|link comment||edited Jul 09 '12 at 12:00 sanjay Expert|
To fall means: to move from a higher to a lower level, typically rapidly and without control:
Bombs could be seen falling from the planes
To fall down means: to be inadequate or unsuccessful; fail:
The deal fell down because there were a number of unanswered questions.
|link||answered Jul 09 '12 at 12:35 Rahul Gupta Expert|
Rahul should have made clear that his definition of "fall down" represents an idiomatic usage and is not the only acceptable meaning.
As Tolley points out, "to fall down" is redundant. Nonetheless, it is often used for emphasis. Being redundant is a stylistic issue, not a grammar error.
|link||answered Jul 09 '12 at 14:11 Jeff Pribyl Grammarly Fellow|
Hero of the day
Person voted on the most questions.