If your quoting from a book or an article, does grammar matter?

asked Oct 05 '13 at 04:13 Amanda Brown New member

2 answers


Grammar always matters, Amanda! 


Well, let's rewind a bit.  Yes, there are certainly times when grammar really doesn't matter.  Talking to your best friend, writing a poem or song, texting, making a joke - these are all times when the reader or listener likely doesn't care one bit about grammar.


Since you are asking about quoting a book or article, I assume that you are talking about formal writing.  In that case, yes, grammar certainly always matters.  The question I think you really want to ask is, "What do I do when I want to quote something that has a grammatical error?"


When you quote someone else's work, you need to write it exactly as it was originally written.  Occasionally you can get away with fixing something very minor, such as an obvious typo, and no one will flinch.  But if it is a major error, or you want to keep the minor error, there is a solution.  You simply put [sic] after the error.  This is a latin word that means "thus".  It is short for sic erat scriptum - "thus was it written."  Foreign words should be in italics, and sic should be put in square brackets as I did above.  This tells the reader, "I know there is an error there, but I'm quoting exactly as it was published." 


Here is an example of the usage:


Amanda Brown asked, "If your [sic] quoting from a book or an article, does grammar matter?"


In case you're not sure why I used it in your sentence:

Your = possessive adjective. 

You're = contraction of you are

link comment answered Oct 05 '13 at 04:43 Patty T Grammarly Fellow

Grammar is important for explanations , and we cannot say exactly the same sentences, we can explain what this mean ? not feeling
names ,dates,places .are not changeable .

in translations we quotes what is the meaning of .

link comment answered Oct 05 '13 at 17:21 Mahjabin Andar New member

Your answer

Write at least 20 characters

Have a question about English grammar, style or vocabulary use? Ask now to get help from Grammarly experts for FREE.