Grammarly says I should use "whom" instead of "who". Should "My" be captilized?

0

His testimony discredits the outlook of those who insist, “I am who I am and cannot change” or “My circumstances are set in stone and cannot budge.” 

asked Jul 06 '13 at 00:59 Susan New member

2 answers


1

Yes, My should be capatilized. 

link answered Jul 06 '13 at 07:50 Koshik Contributor

To me, who is correct. I don't know what other experts have a say on this.

KoshikJul 06 '13 at 07:52

Agreed, it's who.

Michael CranfieldJul 06 '13 at 09:24

add comment
0

I am not sure why these errors were indicated for you.

 

1.)  'Who' is correct since it is in the subjective form - it is the subject of the verb 'insist'.  the objective form 'whom' will only be used as the object of a verb or a preposition.  In the case of an object of a verb, here is an example:

 

Use a relative pronoun as a conjunction [joining word for two or more clauses] in the following 2 simple sentences:

 

This is the man.  I see him.  In the second simple sentence, the object pronoun 'him' is used because it is the object of the verb 'see'.  Now, join these two sentences by using a relative pronoun as a conjunction, and you get:

 

This is the man whom I see.  The objective form 'whom' is used because that is the form that was used for it in the unjoined second simple sentence.  

 

It is always a good idea, when you have uncertainties with the distinction between 'who' and 'whom' to 'unjoin' the two sentences, and see whether you would use a subjective or objective form.

 

As for the example 'I am who I am' - here you have a noun clause complement.  This simply means that the first 'I am' is followed by more information about 'I'.  The verb 'am' is a linking verb - this means it is not an action.  You may follow such a linking verb with an adjective:  I am sick.  You may also follow it with a noun [word, phrase, or clause]:  I am a doctor.  I the case of your example you have a clause [group of words with a subject and an object] that functions as a noun.  This complement is always in the subjective position [although in everyday speaking we often use the objective form].  This means that 'who' [subjective form] has to be used and not 'whom' [objective form].

 

2.)  I am not sure whether you start your sentence with "My circumstances".  Of course, if you do, it should be capitalised because it starts a sentence.  Your context will dictate.

link comment answered Jul 07 '13 at 03:32 Ahmad Barnard Expert

Your answer


Write at least 20 characters

Have a question about English grammar, style or vocabulary use? Ask now to get help from Grammarly experts for FREE.