'stone walls do not make a prison' what is subject and predicate in this sentence.... ???? pls justify the answer too.... :/
I would agree to your comment where you mentioned that the 'prison' is the subject in the given sentence, as this sentence is an adage so it can be confusing.
Now if we take the sentence:
All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy.
Obviously, Jack is the subject here as the sentence is mentioning about him, just like in your sentence, the prison is being described.
Hope my justification is justified. :)
|link||answered Jun 08 '13 at 06:07 Anūp Chakravartī New member|
I understand your confusion when you say that "prison" seems as though it should be the subject. I think it would help if we clarify the difference between "subject" and "topic." The topic of the sentence "Stone walls do not make a prison" may well be prisons, especially if the paragraph this sentence is in is also about prisons. However, the subject of a sentence is a grammatical feature; the subject is the person or thing doing the action of the verb.
In your original sentence, "Stone walls do not make a prison," "stone walls" is the grammatical subject of the sentence. If we turn the sentence around to this, "Prisons are more than stone walls," the word "prisons" is the grammatical subject. However, in both sentences, the topic is "prisons."
|link||answered Jun 09 '13 at 05:00 Dr. G Contributor|
When you ask us to justify the answer, it sure seems like a homework assignment. Further evidence that you are looking for someone else to do your work is the lazy manner of your question.
All sentences begin with a capital letter and end with one punctuation mark. "Pls" is not a word. Practice writing properly to avoid appearing lazy.
If you are instead looking for someone to help you understand how to find the subject and predicate, here is a handy page that explains both:
Also, Schoolhouse Rock explains in a simplified way:
|link||answered Jun 07 '13 at 14:49 Patty T Grammarly Fellow|
Hero of the day
Person voted on the most answers.