Grammar usage

0

What is the difference between "May I smoke here and Can I smoke here?"

asked Feb 19 at 12:53 sanjay Expert

3 answers


2

I disagree with Lewis.  Can has at least 2 meanings: (1) ability, or (2) permission.  When I was a child, growing up in Saskatchewan, Canada, whenever I would ask a permission question using can, my father would rhetorically reply, "I don't know, can you?", which meant that I was using the wrong verb to ask for permission to do something.  In fact, the limitation of can to ability-only contexts is an old wives' tale.  In other words, it is not true.  You can use can to ask for permission.

 

When you are asking for permission to do something, you can use may, can, or could.  May and could are more formal, and thus more polite, than can but all three are acceptable. 

 

May I use your washroom?

Could I use your washroom?

Can I use your washroom?

 

I hope this helps.

link edited Feb 19 at 13:25 Shawn Mooney Expert

Your father may have been related to my mother.

Lewis NeidhardtFeb 19 at 13:46

Thanks.

sanjayFeb 19 at 17:07

Lewis, does this mean that we are related? LOL

Shawn MooneyFeb 19 at 17:27

add comment
1

'May' is used to ask permisission, and 'can' is used to ask ability.

 

'May' is proper in your sentence, unless the lack of oxygen might prevent combustion, unlikely in this case.

 

'Can I climb that tree?' This is asking someone if they believe I am physically capable of climbing the tree.

link answered Feb 19 at 13:14 Lewis Neidhardt Expert

I'm with you, Lewis. We have also had this discussion a number of time in the past months, so I have to say I was surprised to see Sanjay ask about the difference between may & can again.

Patty TFeb 19 at 21:09

See, guys. And this is from a young lass.

Lewis NeidhardtFeb 20 at 01:30

Ha ha ha.... not feeling very young today, but I'll take it!

Patty TFeb 20 at 04:58

add comment
1

Language changes over time. Lewis gives the formal, technically correct -- albeit somewhat outdated -- answer. Shawn gives an answer that reflects actual usage today, although most formal references reject the usage as sloppy.

 

From my reading, British English (including the Canadian variant) appears to be more accepting of can used to ask permission than does American English. Still, one hears the usage more often than not in America.

link answered Feb 19 at 20:36 Jeff Pribyl Grammarly Fellow

I plead age.

Lewis NeidhardtFeb 20 at 01:33

add comment

Your answer


Write at least 20 characters

Have a question about English grammar, style or vocabulary use? Ask now to get help from Grammarly experts for FREE.