“Absolutely, I want you to be my sister ─ that is if you wish,” Allen said and gave her another hug.
Why is the above wrong (my sister- that is if you)
4 answers 
Your sentence is basically okay (and Sanjay's advice was incorrect). But you definitely need a comma after that is, and I think a comma would also be a good idea after said, too. Or the final part of the sentence could be reworded this way: Allen said, before giving her another hug.
| link comment |
answered Feb 12 at 12:36
|
“Absolutely, I want you to be my sister ─ that is if you wished,” Allen said and gave her another hug.
| link |
answered Feb 12 at 04:17
|
It doesn't make sense to change the tense of wish here, Sanjay.
add comment

